Biden Judge HALTS — Trump Order Again

A federal judge has halted President Trump’s revised executive order limiting birthright citizenship, creating a fresh constitutional confrontation just months after the Supreme Court affirmed citizenship rights for children born on American soil.

Judge Rejects White House Authority

U.S. District Judge Deborah Boardman issued a 35-page preliminary injunction against Trump’s August 6 executive order, ruling it violated the Supreme Court’s June decision in Barbara v. Trump. The 5-4 Supreme Court ruling established that children born in the United States to parents unlawfully or temporarily present in the country qualify as citizens under the 14th Amendment. Boardman previously blocked Trump’s original birthright citizenship order before the high court weighed in on the matter.

Trump’s revised order attempted to deny citizenship to children whose parents are classified as alien enemies, including members of designated Foreign Terrorist Organizations, and children born through surrogacy arrangements paid for by foreign parents. The executive order prompted Court Appointed Special Advocates to file suit against the administration.

White House Pushes Back Hard

The administration rejected the ruling as judicial activism. White House spokeswoman Lauren Bis called Boardman an activist judge appointed by Biden attempting to thwart President Trump’s commonsense agenda. The White House maintains the executive order aligns with Supreme Court holdings and analysis on citizenship questions. The ruling marks the first injunction against Trump’s revised birthright order since the Supreme Court’s constitutional decision in June.

Boardman wrote that the 2026 executive order is almost certainly unconstitutional as applied to the certified class because the Supreme Court already decided these children are citizens at birth. The judge expressed concern over the administration’s broad interpretation of who qualifies as an enemy, citing plaintiff allegations about false or speculative conclusions based on markers like tattoos or family connections.

Constitutional Questions Remain

While the Supreme Court acknowledges limited exceptions to birthright citizenship for children of foreign diplomats or those born during hostile occupation, Boardman found Trump’s alien enemy category too expansive. She highlighted two plaintiffs: Andrea, who fled cartel-controlled Mexico and whose child’s father has a relative in a designated group, and Monica, a Venezuelan woman concerned about wrongful links to criminal organizations. Former Justice Department official Abhi Kambli argued Boardman speculated incorrectly about how the administration might misapply the order, noting the legal challenge fails as a facial challenge requiring proof the entire order is unlawful.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Recent

Weekly Wrap

Trending

You may also like...

RELATED ARTICLES